Religious Tourism

Last fall, I returned from a trip to the Baltics. One of the best things about traveling to other countries, in my opinion, is coming into contact with other forms of worship and considering how those “other” sacred spaces and forms of worship feel in contrast to my own experiences as a Mormon. When you enter these places, you have to realize that to their worshipers, past and present, these are the places they have gone to experience the divine, to find comfort, and to understand their place in the universe. Come with me on a tour of some of the places I visited.

20160826_103935Copenhagen’s Cathedral: Church of Our Lady

We started our trip with a day in Copenhagen, Denmark. This first church didn’t make my short list, but my husband wanted to see it, and I’m glad we went!  The original Christus status by Danish sculptor Thorvaldsen is found inside.  The chapel is currently lined with white statues of the apostles (also by Thorvaldsen). The interior is simple and light colored with graceful architectural features like the dome over the altar (see picture). The simplicity of the interior invites silence and reflection and has a feeling of peace and welcome.

There have been several churches built on the same site over the centuries (they kept burning down), with the original one dating to 1209. The current church, like most churches in Northern Europe, is Evangelical Lutheran (since the reformation came to Denmark in 1536). The church is still actively in use; in fact, a friend of mine attended a gay wedding there a week after I visited. Both Kierkegaard and Hans Christian Anderson’s funerals were held in this church. Of all the churches we visited, this one felt the most like a Mormon worship space in terms of mood and architecture.

Rostock, Germany:  St. Mary’s Church

This is a huge red brick Gothic-style 13th century Cathedral (later expanded to a Basilica) that was modified with the reformation to become an Evangelical Lutheran Church. The building still has the smell of wax, incense and moldering dust that I usually associate with Cathedrals, and there are several ornate effigies and a dominating organ. There is a complicated still-working astronomical clock that dates to 1472 with apostles rotating around it. But the real piece de la resistance is seen as you exit the church: an enormous stained glass mural of Christ triumphant. It is truly a sight to behold.

The church fell into disrepair a little during the years Rostock was a part of East Germany. There is no air conditioning and no heating. I am always in awe at the devotion of those who built such lavish spaces for their worship, and wonder how it must have felt over the centuries to gather there and feel a part of such a legacy.

Stockholm, Sweden: the Royal Chapel

20160830_103600We briefly ducked into the royal chapel before visiting the armory (it’s free!). The royal chapel is part of the Church of Sweden, a Lutheran denomination, and was opened in 1754. Unlike other Lutheran denominations which are decidedly low church (less ceremonial), the Church of Sweden uses priests, vestments and a high mass to retain a high church worship service despite being Lutheran. The Church of Sweden is very liberal and ordained its first lesbian bishop in 2009.  63% of Swedes belong to the Church of Sweden, not surprising since until 2000 they were automatically enrolled at birth unless their parents had officially resigned. Only 2% of Swedes attend church regularly, but a whopping 17% consider religion an important part of their lives.


Talinn, Estonia: St. Catherine’s Passage

Image may contain: outdoorWe visited several churches in Tallinn: the Alexander Nevsky Russian Orthodox Church (no interior photos allowed, but it was gorgeous), St. John’s, St. Olaf’s, St. Nicholas’, St. Mary’s and the Church of the Holy Ghost in the town square. But one thing that struck me as we walked down an alley was the gravestones tacked up in St. Catherine’s Passage, one of the oldest alleys in the medieval town of Tallinn. St. Catherine’s was originally an order of Dominican friars, and a church has been in this site since at least 1246. In the 16th century, a Lutheran mob destroyed the church and martyred the friars. The grave stones represent some of the earliest engraved stones in Estonia and are in one of the most charming streets to boot!

St. Petersburg, Russia: The Church of Our Savior on Spilled Blood

20160902_11570920160902_12062220160902_12002320160902_115447

Every Russian Orthodox Cathedral is a work of art. We also saw the elegant Church of St. Peter & Paul where Peter the Great is buried along with other czars and czarinas. It was pretty amazing. But the most incredible site I saw during my trip, bar none, was the interior of the opulent Church of Our Savior on Spilled Blood. The exterior is a work of art, but nothing prepared me for the beauty of the interior. Every surface was covered with mosaics in vibrant colors and gold leaf. The architecture ensured that plenty of light filtered in, bathing religious art in splendor. I was speechless. This cathedral is a fairly recent construction, built between 1803 and 1907. The project was funded by the imperial family on the site of the fatal wounding of Alexander II in 1881. The church was ransacked shortly after its completion during the Russian revolution of 1917. It was used as a morgue during WW2 and a vegetable storage center after that, earning it the sardonic name Saviour on Potatoes.

It is no longer used for worship, although there are many Russian Orthodox churches still in use, including one we visited with our tour guide who informed us it remained in continuous use even during the decades of the Soviet Union. Photos are prohibited in active use Russian Orthodox churches, and women who worship must veil their heads when they enter (although pants are acceptable attire and female guests don’t have to cover their heads).

20160902_160122 20160902_160744St. Petersburg, Russia: St. Isaac’s Cathedral

Like the Church of our Savior on Spilled Blood, St. Isaac’s was a masterpiece of religious art. It was larger and neoclassical rather than Russian medieval like Spilled Blood, but it was still awe-inspiring. Every surface was filled with images to contemplate, and the architecture created an interior that felt vast yet full of light.

St. Isaac’s is the 4th largest Cathedral in the world and is situated very near the square in front of the Winter Palace. It opened in 1858 after 40 years of construction. The Soviet regime stripped it of its religious trappings and in 1931 renamed it the Museum of the History of Religion and Atheism. After the fall of communism, the church resumed worship services in the left altar. The great dome honors the Holy Spirit, and a dove can be seen in its center, ascending or descending, depending on your perspective.

20160903_114052 20160903_141352 Image may contain: indoorHelsinki, Finland: Church of the Rock & Chapel of Silence

Helsinki housed two of the most interesting churches we visited. While we also visited the Russian Orthodox Cathedral (no photos allowed) and the very large Lutheran Church (fairly barren after our Russian churches), there are two very unique and modern churches in Helsinki. The Church of the Rock, completed in 1969, is built directly in granite with rock walls surrounding the center seating and a domed ceiling made from a spiraled copper wire. The acoustic properties of the chapel are world class thanks to the surrounding rock walls and the copper dome. Lutheran services are held here Sunday afternoons.  No services are held in the Chapel of Silence which opened in 2012. Volunteers staff it and are available for confidential conversations with any visitor who requests it. Located in the middle of a busy square, its sound-absorbing architecture offers a quiet sanctuary in a bustling city.

          Image result for stockholm german church stained glassImage result for stockholm german church stained glass

Stockholm, Sweden (again): St. Nicolas Church and the German Church

We spent most of our last day in Gamla Stan, the oldest part of Stockholm. The Church of St. Nicholas houses the amazing gothic statue of St. George slaying the dragon. It’s a pretty cool looking dragon, and I wondered how distracting it would be to see the dragon during worship services, although maybe that just keeps parishioners focused on the struggle between good and evil inside each of us (or more likely the political conflicts with the Danes over the centuries). This Church dates to the 13th century and is made of brick. The German Church dates to the 14th century, and is part of the Church of Sweden. What I found fascinating here was the German-influenced stained glass scenes of family life: a family surrounding a table to share a meal, a family working the farm, a family gathering as a loved one passes from this life. It was a real contrast from the loftier and more symbolic religious art in the other churches we saw, and the stained glass murals created a feeling of home and comfort, an integration of family into the church and church into the family.

Reflections

The familiar is always what’s comfortable, but a religious experience is also supposed to be about getting us out of our comfort zone, provoking us to overcome our base impulses and appealing to our better angels. Visiting these other houses of worship had me thinking about several things and how they alter our worship:

Art. The artwork differed so greatly from church to church and denomination to denomination. Medieval artwork was often used to illustrate the stories of the bible and help the masses visualize the teachings. Symbolic artwork (like the dragon slaying) created room for reflection, even if the sermon was boring. The family scenes in the German Church created a sense that the divine is involved in the domestic, not just reserved for Sunday worship, and that the family rather than the church is the center of life.

Most Mormon chapels have no artwork. My home ward had a picture of Christ knocking at heart’s door behind the choir seats, but I haven’t seen that in other LDS chapels. The focus seems to be on the pulpit and organ pipes, all of which are modern in design and not usually ornate.

Worship Theater. We usually think of the altar as the focal point of Cathedrals, but one thing that struck me as I visited many of the churches was the interplay between the organ and the pulpit, both of which were ornate affairs even in the somewhat stripped down Lutheran churches. The congregant watches from below as the preacher preaches God’s message down to them, and the organ responds to the preacher on behalf of the congregation, raising hymns and singing praises to God. Or maybe the congregants feel like they are watching an overhead tennis match. If so, I suppose their eyes are lifted up as they contemplate the interplay between divine and human.

The only theater I can think of that we engage in as Mormons is the need to perform the sacrament prayer perfectly. The young man who blesses it looks to the stand for a nod of approval, and then the sacrament can be passed to the congregation. In a sense it’s what the church is all about–older men mentoring younger men while the rest of us watch.

Patron Comfort. In Russian Orthodox churches, the congregants don’t sit. In the Lutheran churches, there were wooden pews. Some weeks I struggle to last 3 hours on lightly cushioned seats in our Mormon chapels. How does comfortable seating or lack thereof influence the length and nature of our worship services? Honestly, I don’t see anyone standing for three hours, regardless the type of service.

Modern vs. Ancient.  Worshiping in a centuries old church is a sensation that feels almost like time travel. The smell of it is ancient, thanks to centuries of incense, smoke, candlewax, graves, and dust. It’s an earthy smell. It reminds us of the legacy of religion. Religion is usually inherited, often through multiple generations. Worship is a reminder that we are a link in a chain of devotees, usually within our own families, and also in our communities at large. In many of these countries, there was a historical state religion, so there is a form of nationalist pride associated with attending church. There’s also a solidity, an element of trust with a religion that has the backing of centuries as evidenced by the ancient building in which one worships.

But the more modernized, stripped down Lutheran churches introduced a new line of thinking, removing some of the pomp and institutional church from the worship and instead focusing individuals on Jesus more personally and less ceremoniously. The mood was decidedly different, and it felt more personal for some reason. The most modern churches take this idea even further, stripping away artwork and all the trappings of ceremonial form. Spirituality is found in silent contemplation in a beautiful but removed and unique setting. Within, one can commune with the divine in whatever way is comfortable and compelling for the individual. Worship becomes completely personalized and silent in these most modern settings. The architecture becomes its own metaphor for individualized worship. To quote E.M. Forster’s Mr. Emerson in A Room with a View [pointing at himself with his dinner fork]:

“My vision is within! Here is where the birds sing! Here is where the sky is blue!”

As I think about our Mormon approach, to me it felt more similar to the modern churches than anything else.  The spartan decor seems to say “bring your own spirituality and inspiration,” a very low church approach. Of course, to me that’s comfortable and what church looks like, but religious tourism is a chance to understand what worship looks and feels like to others. Seeing the opposite extreme in the Russian Orthodox Cathedrals, and watching the individual devotion as people lit candles and bowed, I had a twinge of holy envy. But it was wrapped up in the spirit of adventure and novelty of travel.

If I had to choose a place to actually worship, I would have picked the come-as-you-are Chapel of Silence of these options. An oasis in a busy square, it felt most familiar to me, the idea that you can step outside your life at any moment and connect with the divine or regroup before stepping back into the bustle of life. To me, that’s what faith feels like, the breath between actions, the silence between words.

Discuss.

**Originally published at Wheat & Tares.

 

Comments

  1. My favorite spiritual spaces tend to be rather spartan, like the student chapel at MIT. It was designed to host services for all faith traditions. The light filters in from a large skylight and from the bottom of the sidewalls. The sidewall light comes from sunlight reflected off a small moat around the building. I love it and find a peace there that feels like I belong.

  2. Jason K. says:

    It’s no surprise that I love the high church way, but in the end I agree with you: my faith is the breath between actions, the silence between words. (That’s a lovely sentence, btw.)

  3. I was in the Church of Our Lady in Copenhagen a few weeks ago. I agree with everything you said, and I’ll add this: our visitors’ centers have nothing on the real thing. The whole building points to Christ at the front, and the Mormon-like serenity was a real thing. Combined with a rehearsing organ, the whole experience left me completely overwhelmed. 10/10, would recommend visiting there. (On another note, there were maybe 15 tourists in three groups there at the same time as me. All were American, all were Mormon. I asked.)

  4. Love this, Angela. Thanks.

  5. Jason K. says:

    Also: the Church of Our Lady in Copenhagen is one of the best churches I’ve ever visited. There’s something about the light in that place…

  6. Gilgamesh says:

    One of my favorite non-LDS churches to visit is a little Carmelite chapel in San Francisco across the street from St. Ignatius. It is all stone, small with little decoration. It is really easy to miss. On one of my visits, the Vietnamese nuns were chanting the rosary in Latin as I sat in the chapel. It took me back to my mission days in Italy and I could feel their love of God and their devotion to Christ through their chanting.

  7. I really enjoyed reading this. It turns out I’ll be in Copenhagen in two weeks, so I really need to see the Church of Our Lady. And the last sentence of your post took my breath away.

  8. Angela C says:

    gwp: I googled MIT Student Chapel, and it is gorgeous! It reminded me a lot of the two churches in Helsinki, particularly the Chapel of Silence. Very appealing and contemplative.

  9. thanks for sharing!

  10. This is awesome. Thanks for sharing your experience. (I’m full of holy envy.)

  11. Bro. Jones says:

    Thanks for this post–can’t believe I missed it the first time around. Particularly noted your emphasis on smell. I’ve been in some very old Hindu temples, and even new ones have incense burning all the time. Burning incense is even a part of home-based Hindu worship. With the typical Mormon chapel smelling mostly of children (not always pleasantly so), it’s interesting that we’ve never contemplated scent much in our worship.

  12. Quandmeme says:

    As a missionary in France, I loved visiting the little and the big churches. I had a thought once about whether in the resurrection the French peasants would be as destroying angels to raze them as monuments to false traditions and the craftiness of men and the abominable church’s love of materiality and carnality.
    Soon, though I came to feel that the opposite would be true. The structures were consacrated by their sacrifice. The French will come back to rededicate then as temples and monuments of faith.

  13. Quandmeme says:
  14. Russian Orthodox churches are a sight to behold. Really different for a Mormon girl, but not as weird as if I hadn’t lived in Germany and seen many small and large churches. I got a real feel for the late medieval living in Amberg as a kid. Thanks for sharing. I also enjoy seeing churches mosques etc., how people worship. One of my favorite memories of NYC is a Palm Sunday progression in a minor street off Times Square and we joined th em singing the hymns of praise with our car windows open.

  15. Susan Carroll says:

    In Portland Oregon there is a Nunnery. At Christmas they host a live nativity, and a walk through their woods, with stations of his life. Their beautiful chapel is small, made of native stone in Gothic style. They invite local choral groups to come and sing carols in their chapel. An interesting thing, traditional carols and religious music sound magnificent among the Gothic arches, but modern songs like Silver Bells sound truly horrendous! The acoustics are just not compatible.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s